History
In 1093, Bernard de Neufmarché, an Anglo-Norman knight, conquered the Welsh kingdom of Brycheiniog. At his initiative, a castle and a church dedicated to St. John were built in Brecon. According to tradition, Bernard gifted the church to his confessor, Roger, a monk from Battle Abbey, who founded a Benedictine priory there. It is more likely, however, that Bernard founded the monastery, modeled on William the Conqueror and his Battle Abbey, monument to his victory at the Battle of Hastings. The Brecon priory was intended to cement Bernard’s position as the conqueror of Wales.
The first prior of Brecon was Walter, a monk from Battle Abbey. Bernard de Neufmarché endowed it and the entire monastery with lands, privileges, and tithes from subordinate churches, as well as a mill on the River Usk and two more mills on the Honddu. After Bernard’s death, patronage passed to the Earls of Hereford, contributing to the monastery’s even greater development. In the 13th century, the monastery’s benefactors were primarily the Lords of Brecknock and their principal vassals, including William de Braose, Sheriff of Herefordshire, who died in 1211. Thanks to the support of powerful families, the Benedictines of Brecon achieved a significant income in 1291, valued at £20 from the dependent parish churches and over £36 from other sources. Despite this, the priory was not very large. It usually consisted of five or six monks in addition to the prior, and in 1401, even just four. The prior held an important position in the surrounding areas, but was elected at Battle Abbey, from where he could also be called at any time.
In the early 13th century, during the reign of King John, a thorough reconstruction of the priory church began in the early Gothic style. Work began on the chancel and transept, while the liturgy was still being celebrated in the old nave. Further work on the nave, the extension of the church with a northern aisle, and the expansion of the claustrum were carried out in the late 13th and early 14th centuries. In the later years of the 14th century, the south aisle and the Havard family chapel were built. The plans were ambitious, but not all were ultimately realized (the chancel and transept were not vaulted), despite construction work continuing until the end of the Middle Ages. In the 15th century, a magnificent rood screen was built, the chancel roof was replaced, and the tower was raised in several stages. The final stage of work on the latter was likely carried out in the early 16th century.
In the Middle Ages, the priory church was renowned for its impressive gilded rood screen, which separated the nave from the choir and chancel. It was a place of pilgrimage and veneration until it was destroyed during the Reformation. In 1538, the monastery was dissolved, the property seized by the English ruler, Prior Robert Halden dismissed with a life pension, and the monastery church was converted into a parish church. The cloister buildings and most of the monastery’s outbuildings were transferred to Sir John Price, who adapted them for secular purposes. In 1576, his descendant purchased the remainder of the former monastery estate and took over the maintenance of the chancel of St. John’s church.
In the second half of the 18th century, the cloisters and part of the former claustrum buildings were demolished. The monastery church was in poor condition, and by the early 19th century, only the nave remained in use. Minor repairs were carried out in 1816 and 1836 (the slate roof over the chancel and the screen between the nave and chancel), while major renovations to the church began only between 1860 and 1862 and were continued in 1872 by Sir George Gilbert Scott. Due to cracks, the tower was strengthened in 1914. Subsequently, the south transept chapels were rebuilt and the last remaining wing of the former claustrum was modernized. In 1923, the church was raised to the cathedral status.
Architecture
The Benedictine priory was founded on the northeastern side of the castle and on the north side of Brecon town, outside their fortifications. Its southeastern section adjoined the Honddu River, which flowed into the larger riverbed of the River Usk behind the castle and town. The monastery grounds sloped down from the high Pen-y-crug hill to the northwest and ended in steep escarpments above the Honddu to the southeast. A land route ran west in front of the priory, leading from the north to the castle and town to the south. The entire monastery complex was surrounded by a stone wall, with the main entrance gate situated on the northwestern side. Near the gate, a rectangular building stood against the wall, likely associated with the distribution of alms to pilgrims.
The monastery church of St. John ultimately had the form of a basilica, built on a Latin cross plan, with a relatively short length of 62 meters. First, in the early 13th century, a rectangular chancel was built, along with transept with two pairs of chapels on the eastern side and a quadrangular tower at the crossing, which was raised at the turn of the 15th and 16th centuries. The aisled, five-bay nave was built in the English Decorated Gothic style somewhat later than the eastern part of the church, at the turn of the 13th and 14th centuries. It was characterized by a very wide central nave compared to the narrow side aisles, and, even more unusually, a southern aisle one bay shorter, giving the church’s western façade an asymmetrical appearance. In the 14th century, the impressive Havard Chapel was added to the northern wall of the chancel, built on the site of the two older chapels by the transept. In the same century, the outer of the southern chapels was removed, while in the 15th century, the inner chapel was divided into two smaller ones to create a sacristy and an upper floor.
The church’s exterior facades were relatively simple, devoid of decoration apart from a few cornices. The base of the walls was framed by a chamfered plinth, omitted for unknown reasons at the northern transept, which was executed with lower-quality stonework than the older chancel. The verticality of the facades was accentuated by stepped buttresses, reinforcing the walls everywhere except on the southern side of the nave and transept (where the claustrum buildings ensured structural stability). The crown of the walls was originally topped by a parapet (without supporting consoles) with battlements. The parapet surrounded the tower’s hip roof and the gable roofs of the remaining sections of the church. These roofs were initially high, steeply sloping over the nave and chancel, but were lowered in the 15th century when a new roof truss was installed.
Both aisles were lit by large pointed windows with three-light tracery. The north wall of the nave featured two-light windows with forked tracery, while the south wall featured three-light windows with interlacing tracery, all of the type popular in Herefordshire in the early 14th century. More unusual was the addition of a second window in the fourth bay of the north aisle in the second quarter of the 14th century, set at the level of the aisle’s roof. This was likely due to the addition of an elaborate tomb niche in the nave at that time, enclosed by a high, moulded ogee arcade. The older, early Gothic chancel and transept windows were characterized by much narrower and also higher openings. The distinctive eastern elevation of the chancel was pierced by five lancet-shaped openings arranged in a pyramidal pattern, while each bay of the chancel was lit by three similar openings to the south and north. One of these triads in the south wall was replaced by a three-light tracery window in the 14th century. Triads of lancets in a pyramidal pattern were also pierced in both gable walls of the transept, supplemented with small, single-light windows on the west.
The main entrance to the church from the outside was located in the north aisle, at the second bay from the west, where a porch with a chamber on the first floor was installed in the 15th century. Its façade, in addition to the pointed portal and the two-light window on the first floor, featured three niches for carved figures. The portal inside the porch acquired a moulding typical of the 13th century, so it must have been moved from another place during the construction of the north aisle in the 14th century. A pointed, moulded portal in the north wall of the transept was intended for the use of the monks, as well as a processional portal in the eastern part of the south aisle, connected to the cloister and, further on, to the most important rooms of the claustrum. A portal connecting the south aisle with the western part of the cloister may have had a more utilitarian purpose.
Inside the church, a wooden rood screen separated the nave from the space beneath the tower. Initially, in the 13th century, it was a relatively simple screen along the chancel arcade, likely with two pointed portals flanking the altar. In front of it, a portal from the cloister led from the south. In the 14th century, after the nave was completed, a second screen may have been added at the boundary of the last two bays of the central nave. In the 15th century, it acquired an exceptionally impressive form (the so-called Golden Rood Screen), with a façade likely decorated with carved and gilded tracery motifs. The screen featured an upper gallery, or loft, set against the walls on stone corbels, accessible by stairs extending through the thickness of the northern wall. On the upper floor, on the north and south sides, there were two passages, along with stairs extending through the thickness of the southern wall, ensuring orderly circulation for pilgrims. Above the balcony, at a height of approximately 3 meters, were figures of the Crucifixion and symbols of the Evangelists, all painted and gilded.
The nave was divided into aisles by tall, pointed arcades supported by massive, octagonal piers, with the northern row having a different archivolt moulding (small alternating grooves and convexities) from the southern row (double chamfering with a dividing groove). The aisles opened onto the transept with additional arcades with stepped, pointed archivolts, while the central nave faced east with a tall arcade set on wall columns with moulded capitals (the inner pair was shortened and suspended on consoles due to the rood screen). These columns formed part of the profile of the four massive tower piers and the base of further tall arcades at the crossing. Originally, the nave was also divided by wooden screens, demarcating numerous chapels in the aisles, belonging to guilds and wealthy families. The space behind the rood screen was accessible only to the monks. The choir had two rows of wooden stalls, while the southern wall of the chancel, since the 14th century, housed tripartite stone sedilia with moulded trefoil heads. Their individual seats were separated by small columns with capitals, one of which being reset from an older, 12th-century church. The choir was separated from the chancel at the crossing by the aforementioned wooden screeen, so circulation from it was directed north and south, through moulded portals to the side chapels. Both portals were equipped with pointed archivolts with polygonal shafts, set on columns with moulded capitals and circular bases. A spiral staircase was placed in the southwest corner of the transept, leading to the upper gallery, where the entire transept could be circumnavigated within the thickness of the wall. The gallery continued into the walls of the tower, where a complex system of stairs and passages was installed, which later led to problems with statics.
The interior of the church was never vaulted during the Middle Ages. Despite preparations for vaulting in the chancel, chapels, and transept, all spaces were originally topped by a timber roof truss. In the chancel, the windows on the interior sides were framed by slender columns, featuring moulded capitals, mid-height rings, and bases supported by the window cornice and consoles at the edge of each bay. Very similar wall-columns were also placed for the planned vault, for which the eastern corners of the chancel were specifically modified (the installation of the wall-columns must therefore have been later than the chancel’s construction, but close enough to that period that they acquired similar forms to the window columns). In the second quarter of the 15th century, the original chancel truss with its high, sloping roof, was replaced with a lower, late-medieval roof. The new truss, opened to the interior, was then decorated with painted floral ornamentation in green and yellow and lead stars mounted on the main rafters.
The buildings of the monastery claustrum were situated on the south side of the nave, with the western wing adjacent to the western end of the southern aisle, and the eastern wing extending the transept. The two wings were connected by the southern wing. All three wings, along with the church and cloisters, traditionally surrounded a garth – rectangular in plan, with the longer axis running north to south. The cloisters were constructed of stone arcades, separated by columns composed of three shafts (trefoil-shaped in cross-section). It were likely not glazed, but they nevertheless provided protection from rain with mono-pitched roofs.
The western wings of Benedictine abbeys typically housed pantries and lay brothers’ quarters, but in Brecon, due to the small convent and large numbers of pilgrims, the rooms on two floors may have been reserved for visitors. According to tradition, the first floor was designated as a pilgrim dormitory. The ground floor may have housed a refectory, auxiliary rooms, and pantries. Furthermore, the western wing housed a gate, providing access from the cloister to the area on the western side of the claustrum. Movement between the ground floor, first floor, and attic floor was provided by stone stairs embedded in the thickness of the eastern wall. Wooden stairs or ladders may also have been present. The adjacent southern wing likely housed the monks’ kitchen and refectory.
The eastern wing contained two floors, the lower of which housed the chapter house and perhaps a fraternity. The first floor in the eastern wings was traditionally designated as a dormitory and latrines. The latter might have been located in the southernmost part of the wing, facing the river, well beyond the southern wing. The eastern corner of the wing adjoined two further buildings, situated perpendicular to each other. One might have housed the prior’s residence, the other quarters for the monastery’s most important guests. The southern house on the ground floor contained a large, hall, opened to the roof truss, separated from the rest of the building by a transverse passage-like vestibule. The vestibule was accessible through a pointed arch, uniformly chamfered along its entire height. A second, slightly smaller hall was located in the northern house, in the eastern part. Both were heated by open hearths, from which smoke rose through the roof truss. The western part of the northern house could have been occupied by the kitchen, which could conveniently supply both halls.
Current state
The former priory church is now one of the most important examples of a large sacral building in Wales, built in the Early Gothic style (chancel, transept) and High Gothic style (nave), although it has not escaped early modern interventions over the centuries. The medieval parapet at the crown of the walls have been removed and replaced with a parapet supported by corbels, the external wall of the south aisle has been partially rebuilt, and the north windows of the Havard Chapel have been replaced. A completely modern addition is the sacristy on the site of the south chapel and the adjacent St. Laurence Chapel, both built on medieval foundations (their walls feature relocated original 13th-century eastern windows, the original piscina and vaulting corbels).
Inside the church, of the numerous chapels that once stood, only the north Keyne’s Chapel remains, originally a cobblers’ guild chapel, still separated by a medieval wooden screen. Unfortunately, no precise descriptions of the construction of the gilded rood screen separating the nave from the choir have survived. Its scale and dimensions are only hinted at by the preserved traces of passageways to the upper loft, located at the end of the nave above the pulpit and on the opposite wall, and the stone corbels used to support its structure. Worthy of note are the numerous original windows from the 13th and 14th centuries, the arcades between the nave and aisles and the transept, the tomb niche in the north aisle, two impressive portals from the former choir to the chapels, and the portal from the north chapel to the chancel. Also are the restored early Gothic sedilia, the small columns flanking the window openings, and the wall-shafts of the unfinished medieval vault (the current one dates from the 19th century). Of the original church furnishings, a beautiful stone font from the 12th century and the hollowed stone for the oil have survive.
Among the priory former buildings, the west wing has survived, rebuilt in the early modern period and now serving as the canonry and sacristy. In the 18th century, it was extended southward and then remodeled in the 19th century in the Neo-Gothic style. A 14th-century cinquefoil window and the original portal are visible from the west. Another 14th-century three-light window is in the eastern façade, which was raised to form a tower in the 19th century. Inside, a medieval hallway with a staircase and a 15th-century fireplace, relocated from elsewhere, have been preserved. The south and east wings, along with the cloisters, are completely demolished. However, buildings identified as the prior’s house and the guest house are still visible, both significantly enlarged and modified in the 17th and 19th centuries. A gatehouse and a section of wall in the northwestern part of the complex are of medieval origin.
bibliography:
Burton J., Stöber K., Abbeys and Priories of Medieval Wales, Chippenham 2015.
Gwynne-Jones D.M., Brecon Cathedral c.1093-1537. The Church of the Holy Rood, “Brycheiniog”, 24/1992.
Haslam R., The buildings of Wales. Powys (Montgomeryshire, Radnorshire, Breconshire), London 1979.
Salter M., Abbeys, priories and cathedrals of Wales, Malvern 2012.
The Royal Commission on the Ancient and Historical Monuments of Wales, The Cathedral Church of St. John the Evangelist, Brecon. An Architectural Study, Brecon 1994.
Wooding J., Yates N., A Guide to the churches and chapels of Wales, Cardiff 2011.